Without phantom menace, i would not be a huge star wars fan. The prequels get a lot of hate, but im fairly confident that any star wars fan in the 2030 age demographic can attribute it to the prequels. Watch adam drivers hilarious response to whether the. The star wars prequels werent kind to ol anakin skywalker. Anyone like the prequels more than the original trilogy. Revenge of the sith is the quintessential star wars prequel. When star wars was first released by the maker george lucas on may 25th, 1977, it instantly became a groundbreaking, worldwide, pop culture phenomenon. The fight between quigon and darth maul on tatooine is one such example of this but in the phantom menace, it gets better. Id say the best sw movie is better than the best trek movie wrath of khan, which is still really really good, and the worst sw movie i or ii, depending on my mood is still better than half the trek movies. To believe the conventional wisdom, the prequel trilogy of the star wars saga 1999s episode i. That means i only ever saw star wars at home and not in the theater.
Lucasfilm after he forgave him for farting in the elevator. At their worst, the prequels signal a troubling lack of interest from writerdirector. Can you spot the person who thinks the star wars prequels are better than the originals. What i miss about the prequels the ubiquitous bashing of the star wars prequels has become practically unavoidable. But on whole, star wars fans like the phantom menace, attack of the clones, and revenge of the sith. The force awakens was going to be better than the prequels. To get a better sense of how they view the star wars universe we asked three deeply passionate fans to share their thoughts on the prequels. What the average star wars fan doesnt realize is that half of star wars is the soundtrack, and episodes 2 and 3 had the best soundtracks in the series. If i could play god with george lucass masterpiece george lucas had some very good ideas with star wars. The prequels, clunky and uneven though they were, still managed to maintain a sense of what makes star wars star wars. But i can tell you as a fan that doesnt like the prequels, but rather as a fan that loves the prequels, i hate it when people give me hyperbolic. The infamous star wars holiday special, often described as the worst tv show of all time, wasnt always that awful. Why the star wars prequels are better than the originals.
Clone wars ending closes the book on the star wars prequels. There are some blogs that fans have written as well. What would be the best way to restructure and improve the. Say what you will about george lucas film making abilities, but without his prequels, the clone wars would not exist. Star wars witze, star wars jokes, funny star wars, prequel memes, cant stop laughing, inka, the funny, dankest memes. If you hated the star wars prequels you probably werent. Its become something of a truism to say that the star wars prequels are. And then the phantom menace came, and we found out that anakin was a whiny kid who grew into an angsty teenager who threw fits whenever things got difficult. The new star wars films are better than the prequels and the. The new star wars trilogy is worse than the prequels cnet. Ah, to be young, dumb, and full of midichlorians again. They were written from the perspective of someone watching a series of movies and then intentionally inverting things to be different.
The obvious answer is that the prequels were made in the 90s 00s while the first films were made in the 70s and 80s, therefore real world technology was more advanced when the films were made. If the prequels were horseshoes, lucas would be a winner. Here is my explanation why i like them over the ot and the st. Star wars toys, books and magazines littered my room. I heard there might have been a little bit of a discussion about this. You wished desperately they would make more movies you groaned when you heard they were making prequels instead you bought a ticket. Why the star wars prequels are better than the sequels the. Man this thread is gonna get destroyed by star wars nerds anyway, i agree with you man, i even considered starting a thread like this a while ago the old ones are alot better, but the prequels are pretty damn entertaining, and i even liked jar jar binks. Coming from a huge star wars fan who has seen all 6 more times than i can count, i prefer revenge of the sith to jedi as well. You just cant have a conversation about these movies without someone bringing up the same old talking points that im not even going to repeat here because if you are the kind of person to read this blog, you know what they are. Even the hobbit prequels to the lord of the ring series dont score much above the star wars prequels, and yet no one feels betrayed, by those films.
Sequels and prequels that were better than the original. So the only way to make the audience engaged with the story of. The star wars prequels could have been so much better. Fans and critics alike scrutinized the star wars prequels ruthlessly upon release, with the long list of complaints resulting in lucas stepping back from directing any more. Dec, 2015 one of the soldiers asked the girls star if star wars. Star wars episodes i, ii, and iiiubiquitously known simply as the prequels, due to their notoriety for being badare loved and appreciated by some, but are seen by others as a stain on the good name that is the star wars franchise. Even phantom menace, my least favorite star wars movie of all time, is so much better than the seque. The best version of the star wars prequels is still the. They had their supporters too, but the vast majority did not come around on them until quite recently. Anyone who remembers watching the phantom menace for the first time, whether youre young or old and whether you liked it or hated it, what was your experience. Why the star wars prequels are much better than everyone thinks. The prequels were better than the force awakens geeks. Why george lucas really made the star wars prequels. Apr 04, 2018 the prequelist in me felt like it was time for the infamous pt to get the same treatment as its successors.
Finally, after stalling for two movies, george lucas delivers on all his promises. His masterpiece saga was not only meant to be anakin skywalker darth vaders life jo. Its universally agreed that the star wars prequels are terrible, but there is one thing they do better than disneys sequels. Its rarely acknowledged that the star wars prequels have some of the best sword fights in cinematic history. The star wars prequel trilogy is a series of epic spaceopera films written and directed by george lucas. The prequels have brought more facts to star wars lore but didnt develop those ideas fully in the films proper.
Prequels are an inherently bad idea, and they are generally executed in a manner that makes them even worse, retreading imagery from the movies ostensibly after them as selfimportant foreshadowing, and glibly trading in self. The really frustrating thing is that they could have been even better than. It changed both cinema and box office forever and spawned the biggest worldwide franchise there is, and with two sequels, one of the greatest trilogies in cinema. Dec 11, 2017 the star wars prequel trilogy isnt as bad as you may remember, and worth revisiting before the last jedi. The star wars prequels were better than the original trilogy. Yes, this time we tackle the totally new question of which star wars movies are better.
The rise of skywalkers c3po twist relates to the prequels erik swann view profile covering superheroes, scifi, comedy, and almost anything else in film and tv. For a second, i thought you were going to crowdsource your opinionated article with anecdotes instead of arguments. Return of the jedi, although it has its moments, is just really not a good movie. It did start out to be a lot better with a different script. Or check out some laughable races from star trek because, well, we like to cover our nerdy bases here at cracked. Its still early going, but it looks an awful lot like the new era of star wars is going out of its way to avoid acknowledging the prequelsor, in other words, the whole section of. I actually like the star wars prequels nerds on earth. My list seems to constantly fluctuate, especially tlj. Lor san tekkas mention of balance in the force wasnt just a wink towards to. The prequels, supplemented with tcw, told a great story of a heros fall. Your answers will be a huge help, but as a huge star wars fan im just really curious to see your responses. And stop by our top picks to see seanbaby kicking our george lucas cutout right in the cardboard.
There is a messy thing with prequels not only the star wars prequels, and its the fact that we already know how the story ends. The lightsaber fights in the prequels, at least when it comes to choreography, are far superior to their original trilogy counterparts. Sequels debate with a deep dive into box office results, tomatometer scores, and the characters and moments that make us love star wars so damn much. All of them were absolutely terrible in every way, except as. Having talked about the tone, lets talk about the look of rogue one. Any star wars fan who is vocal about their hatred of the prequels based. The star wars prequels did one thing better than the sequels chris edwards. Why the star wars prequels are much better than everyone. Not only are the new star wars films better than the prequels they might be better than the originals come at us, bros. I really didnt expect to do crack vids, but after watching star wars so many times, i started having ideas and jokes.
Dear young people who have star wars prequel nostalgia. Watch adam drivers hilarious response to whether the force. The sequel trilogy is brilliant so far, but it feels entirely different im not sure whether thats good or bad. The clone wars is one of the most celebrated pieces of star wars media out there. It isnt for me to say how you should feel about them. That also means i was still a child when episode 1 came out.
Here is why the prequels are better than the originals or. May 24, 2016 i really didnt expect to do crack vids, but after watching star wars so many times, i started having ideas and jokes. Topher grace edited the star wars prequels into one 85. The ultimate news source for music, celebrity, entertainment, movies, and current events on the web. Its an interesting film to be sure, i wonder how we will all feel in 10 years. Lets have you get to know this blonde girl a little better, shes sticking. As the disney star wars trilogy draws to a close with the rise of skywalker, which opens dec. Why is technology so advanced in the star wars prequels. D it pisses me off that some people, like the post above mine, dont let you like the movies and say that our opinion is wrong. I had never seen them before but i have heard so much good about the series that i just had to watch them. Star wars the prequels the good and the bad i know not all fans enjoyed the prequels, so as a life long fan of star wars i am going to list my top good and bad points of the dreaded prequel saga. May 18, 2017 why the star wars prequels are much better than everyone thinks. Like i said in my how many times vid, im really happy to do some goofy stuff.
The writing in the other two are better but to me the aesthetic of a movie is just. Star wars prequels did one thing better than the disney sequels. But theres nearuniversal relief that it doesnt stink that the newest addition to the star wars franchise is parsecs better than the three. Gamers react to star wars jedi fallen order darth vader entrance duration. The star wars prequels were better than the original. As an 11 year old, i thought phantom menace was the greatest thing ever. Before you take up your torches and pitchforks hear me out. It brought a wealth of new and interesting tales within the lore, and almost retroactively makes the prequels better. The star wars prequels have a different structure than the original trilogy. Some days im really positive on it, other days less so. He is basically evil so that from a narrative perspective.
Star wars fans are massively downvoting antiprequel. We compare the star wars prequel trilogy to the sequel trilogy. The trilogy was released from 1999 to 2005 and is a prequel to the original star wars trilogy 197783. Rogue one has been called a lot of thingsa star wars story, an anthology film, a standalone adventuremany of which are synonyms for prequel. It should be noted that the star wars prequel trilogy is almost 7 hours in total length, and the shortest. In fact, the entire third act of clones, from the arena fight to the first clone war battle to anakin and padmes secret wedding, is the greatest contribution the prequels make to. Oct 15, 2019 the star wars prequel trilogy isnt as hated as it used to be by most fans, but that doesnt mean its better than disneys sequel trilogy. Thus, the end of his contributions, and the sequel trilogy, will usher in a new age for the star wars franchise. Before 1999, all we knew is that he was a dad and that he was awesome evil personified. The star wars prequels are not better than disneys sequel. Written and directed by george lucas, the star wars prequels were once the easy punching bag of the fandom, especially in the stillearly days of the internet, and while critical opinion still skews more negative, amongst fans its started to shift.
And in the long run, star wars fans are probably better for having them. Why are the star wars prequels better than the sequels. Hampered by two decades worth of expectations and hype, george lucass deep dive back into the star wars universe was destined to disappoint. Episode i the phantom menace 1999, episode ii attack of the. The star wars prequels are better than the original trilogy both the prequels and originals are really great, but the prequels have more exciting action, i like the cast more, the romance isnt as bad as everyone makes it out to be, jar jar isnt as annoying as everyone says he is, and revenge of the sith may be my favorite movie of all time. Why rogue one is better than every george lucas prequel. For more extended universe shaming, check out 6 star wars characters too retarded for film. How one star wars fan rewrote the prequels and did it better than lucas. One of the soldiers asked the girls star if star wars.
The star wars prequels did one thing better than the sequels. Not too long ago, i saw the 6 star wars movies in chronological order. The very best sequels and prequels earn comparisons with their predecessors, and it would be difficult to argue that the star wars prequels are better than the original trilogy. His problem was in how he tried to execute the ideas. But im curious if there is any sort of in universe explanation with an official source. If we discount some parts of aotc, the prequels are mighty fine movies. The main forward momentum of disneys star wars is the sequel trilogy the force awakens, the last jedi, and the untitled episode ix and if the prequels are going to be canonized in fans eyes then its here where the groundwork needs to be laid. If you hated the star wars prequels you probably werent paying attention. Why are the prequels better than the originals in your mind. Why george lucas really made the star wars prequels, according to kathleen kennedy erik swann. People dont hate the star wars prequels because they are bad movies. Even though it wasnt his sole responsibility, it was the finale of the narrative he devoted so much time to create. The star wars prequels are so excessively guilty of abandoning logic to shoe horn characters in that fans had to make up a bunch of wild theories to try to make a couple of characters fit better. Nutrek is better than all the prequels, and the irony of it being quite purposely modeled after star wars should not be lost on anyone.
Why the star wars prequels are better than the sequels by rachael lind jan 16th, 2020, 10. The star wars prequels are better than the original trilogy. Revenge of the sith, moved closer to lucass originals, but many fans felt betrayed. How george lucas almost accidentally made a masterpiece a. We see the jedi council in the prequels as this glorious institution that, continuously, makes questionable decisions, but the only people to question the jedi councils actions are villains. The prequel trilogy, no matter how you try and spin it they look better, they utilized new technology more. Mar 17, 2020 sequels and prequels that were better than the original. Its become something of a truism to say that the star wars prequels are pretty awful films. What is the best alternative version of the star wars prequels.
I absolutely love solo, dont care what anyone says. Nov 22, 2015 belated media has done well and we are still waiting for epi iii. While there are elements that rhyme, like the way anakin destroys the droid control ship and qui gons death, it. The absolute silliest excuse was when they brought in c3po so that viewers could enjoy more of his witty banter with r2d2. As i watched them as an 23yearold adult, i have no nostalgia for any of the movies what so ever. Like most children of the 1980s, i grew up surrounded by star wars. Sep 21, 2016 the plot of star wars is betterknown than the declaration of independence or the ten commandments. Why i love the star wars prequels and you should too. Why the star wars prequels are better than the sequels. And the darth vader outfit was the holy grail of halloween costumes.
519 1030 1112 1643 1293 1442 264 377 579 1248 43 1381 48 1566 714 317 835 1647 479 461 282 603 1475 737 126 217 982 1215 1202 555 1175 1215 542 333 1428 196 1273